From Proof to Concept: Converting Success Stories Into New Customers

From Proof to Concept: Converting Success Stories Into New Customers

To explore the art and science behind leveraging success stories as persuasive tools in customer acquisition, our host Kathleen (Timbol) Abdeen, Director of Field and Product Marketing, was joined by industry veterans Angela Ferrante and Ryan Quindlen from Laudable.
Nainika Sharma
Content Marketer
May 5, 2023

In today's competitive business landscape, effectively showcasing the tangible value of your products or services is paramount. It's not enough to simply boast about your achievements — you need to transform those success stories into compelling concepts that resonate with potential customers, igniting their interest and driving them toward conversion. 

To explore the art and science behind leveraging success stories as persuasive tools in customer acquisition, our host Kathleen (Timbol) Abdeen, Director of Field and Product Marketing, was joined by industry veterans Angela Ferrante and Ryan Quindlen from Laudable. 

As they talked about the power of storytelling and creating compelling customer stories, we unraveled the strategies that enable businesses to harness the true potential of their success stories, elevating them from mere anecdotes to persuasive narratives that captivate audiences.

Let's go over some critical insights from the webinar. 

Knowing our speakers

Angela, the CEO and founder of Laudable, is passionate about amplifying customer voices. With a strong belief in the power of customer testimonials, she has developed innovative software and services to uncover hidden gems within existing data. Angela's mission is to identify those happy customers who are eager to share their positive experiences but may go unnoticed. Using call recording data, she and her team unearth stories of success, wins, and mentions of a company's product or service.

Furthermore, they provide various avenues, such as video, audio, and other mechanisms, to help businesses broadcast these stories and make a lasting impact. Angela's dedication to customer satisfaction and the art of storytelling is the driving force behind Laudable's success.

On the other hand, Ryan, a valuable member of Angela's team, describes himself as a customer success coach. His role involves understanding the customer's needs and recommending tailored strategies based on their industry and the feedback received from their own customers. Ryan's expertise lies in identifying the most effective plays and approaches that align with the customer's goals. By diving deep into customer sentiments and insights, he helps businesses navigate their way to success by leveraging the power of customer satisfaction. Ryan's enthusiasm for customer success and ability to translate customer feedback into actionable recommendations make him an asset to the Laudable organization.

Unleashing the power of testimonials for business success

Customer testimonials can significantly influence purchase decisions, and extensive data and studies back this. A notable statistic from a recent demand report revealed that 97% of B2B customers consider testimonials and peer recommendations the most reliable content. Delving into the psychology behind this phenomenon, Angela identifies several fundamental principles that underscore the power of customer testimonials.

One such principle is social proof, extensively explored by Robert Cialdini in his book. When uncertain about a particular course of action, people naturally look to others for guidance. In the context of purchasing software or making business decisions, testimonials from similar companies with comparable sizes, stages, and job titles hold significant weight. The principle of social proof is particularly potent when customers perceive those providing testimonials as relatable or similar to themselves.

Additionally, the halo effect comes into play, wherein perceiving someone as trustworthy can extend their credibility to the company or product they endorse. When customers regard an individual testimonial as positive and reliable, it can create a positive perception of the entire organization. This "halo" of trustworthiness can enhance the company's reputation, fostering confidence and attracting potential customers.

Furthermore, storytelling plays a pivotal role in the effectiveness of testimonials. Humans are wired to connect with narratives, and storytelling is a powerful tool for conveying information. When customers share their experiences in a compelling and relatable manner, it enhances retention and resonates deeply with prospective buyers. Storytelling allows for a more emotional and engaging connection, making the testimonials more memorable and impactful.

Considering these psychological principles, Angela highlights the immense significance of customer testimonials. They provide social proof, cultivate trust, and leverage the persuasive power of storytelling. By harnessing the power of customer testimonials, businesses can establish credibility, build a positive brand image, and meaningfully influence purchasing decisions.

Repurposing customer stories for maximum impact across channels

Repurposing customer stories across channels is a great way to use your existing content effectively and expand your reach. Different formats and platforms allow you to appeal to different audiences and capture their attention at various customer journey stages.

One example of repurposing customer stories is using them on your demo conversion page. By embedding a video or quote from a customer, you can provide social proof that can increase conversions. Another example is creating micro case studies or customer stories for social media. Using a generative AI tool like ChatGPT, you can quickly create short-form stories with social graphics that can be shared on LinkedIn or other platforms to drive traffic to your website.

It's important to match the problem to the solution when repurposing customer stories. Instead of pigeonholing your case studies to one specific use, consider how to use them across the entire funnel to maximize their impact. You can create a cohesive content strategy that engages customers and drives conversions by repurposing your customer stories.

Tracking ROI of customer stories

Tracking your customer stories' return on Investment (ROI) requires a granular approach and clear KPIs. Start by identifying specific goals for each customer story use case. For example, if your objective is to increase the demo conversion rate on a particular page, focus on tracking the impact of customer stories in that specific context.

To track ROI effectively, it's essential to have an attribution platform or system in place. This allows you to accurately assign value and measure your customer stories' impact. Using such a platform, you can track conversions, engagement metrics, and other relevant KPIs for each repurposed customer story.

For instance, if you repurpose a customer story as a video for social media, monitor metrics such as views, shares, comments, and click-through rates. Use tracking tools and analytics to measure the direct impact of these videos on website traffic, conversions, and, ultimately, revenue.

Similarly, for customer stories embedded in demo conversion pages or used for demand generation, track the specific metrics associated with those channels. Monitor the conversion rate of the demo page, analyze the engagement and response to any videos, and measure the resulting impact on lead generation and revenue.

By focusing on the individual performance of each repurposed customer story and aligning it with specific KPIs, you can track the results more effectively. Over time, you can aggregate these individual successes into a comprehensive picture of the overall impact of customer stories on your business.

Crafting compelling customer stories that drive results 

Creating a compelling customer story requires a strategic approach that maximizes social proof and extracts valuable insights from customer conversations. Ryan shares a simple yet revealing test for establishing social proof — how many clicks does it take for a website visitor to encounter customer testimonials or quotes? He encourages businesses to run this test themselves and evaluate the accessibility of customer proof on their websites. This "social proof audit" helps gauge the prominence of customer stories and their impact on visitors.

Ryan further emphasizes optimizing customer conversations to get more ROI. He shares an example of a customer who excels at generating multiple assets from each customer story, aiming for at least six assets per conversation. This approach highlights the value of using customer stories across various formats and channels beyond a traditional case studies page buried deep within a website.

Angela introduces the Laudable playbook, which features over 50 "plays" or strategies for leveraging customer stories. These plays allow businesses to take snippets from customer stories and repurpose them in unexpected formats and channels. Angela highlights that the purpose is not just to implement all the plays blindly but to carefully select and adapt them based on the specific needs and goals of the business.

To create compelling customer stories, Angela suggests three key components: 

  • First, research and dig into the available data, such as call recordings from tools like Gong, Chorus, or Zoom. Valuable metrics and impactful soundbites can often be found within those conversations. 
  • Second, gather information from different levels of stakeholders within the organization to capture a comprehensive view of the impact. Perspectives from users, buyers, and higher-level decision-makers offer different insights. 
  • Third, instead of putting stakeholders on the spot during conversations, give them a chance to quantify the impact in advance. This approach encourages thoughtful responses and deeper exploration of the value generated.

Frequently asked questions about converting customer success stories into new customers

  • What are success stories?
    Success stories highlight the achievements, positive outcomes, and benefits experienced by existing customers or clients have used a particular product, service, or solution.
  • How can success stories be converted into new customers?
    Success stories can be powerful marketing tools to attract new customers by showcasing real-life examples of how your product or service has solved problems or delivered value to existing customers. This can build trust and credibility and demonstrate potential customer benefits.
  • What makes a success story effective in converting new customers?
    Effective success stories typically have the following characteristics:

-> Relevance: The success story should be relatable to the target audience and address their pain points or needs.

-> Specificity: The story should provide concrete details about the customer's experience, such as measurable results, specific challenges faced, and how the product or service resolved them.

-> Authenticity: Genuine success stories with real customers are more compelling than fabricated or exaggerated ones.

-> Emotional appeal: Success stories that evoke emotions and positively impact the customer's life or business are more likely to resonate with potential customers.

-> Visual elements: Incorporating visuals such as images, infographics, or videos can enhance the impact of success stories.

  • How can success stories be utilized to attract new customers?
    Success stories can be utilized in various ways, including:

-> Testimonials: Sharing success stories as customer testimonials on websites, landing pages, or social media platforms.

-> Case studies: Developing comprehensive case studies that delve into the customer's journey, challenges, solutions, and outcomes.

-> Content marketing: Creating blog posts, articles, or whitepapers that feature success stories as real-life examples.

-> Video testimonials: Record interviews with satisfied customers who share their success stories and experiences.

-> Webinars or seminars: Organizing live or recorded sessions where customers share their success stories and answer questions from potential customers.

  • How can success stories be tailored to different target audiences?
    Success stories can be customized by focusing on specific industry verticals, use cases, or customer segments to cater to different target audiences. Highlighting success stories relevant to a particular audience's needs, challenges, or aspirations can increase the likelihood of converting them into new customers.
  • How can success stories be measured in terms of their impact on new customer conversion?
    Measuring the impact of success stories on new customer conversion can be challenging but possible through various means, such as

-> Lead tracking: Monitoring the source of leads or inquiries and identifying if success stories played a role in generating interest or inquiries.

-> Conversion rates: Analyzing conversion rates before and after incorporating success stories into marketing materials to gauge their impact.

-> Surveys or feedback: Gather feedback from new customers about success stories' role in their decision-making process.

-> Social media engagement: Monitoring the engagement levels, shares, or comments on social media platforms when success stories are shared.

  • Are there any ethical considerations when using success stories to convert new customers?
    Yes, there are ethical considerations to keep in mind, including

-> Consent: Ensuring that customers providing success stories have given their explicit consent to share their experiences publicly.

-> Accuracy: Representing success stories accurately and truthfully without misleading information or exaggeration.

-> Anonymity or confidentiality: Respect customers' privacy who prefer to remain anonymous or not disclose sensitive information.

-> Endorsement disclosure: Indicating if the success story includes any form of endorsement or compensation to maintain transparency and comply with advertising regulations.

  • Can success stories be used for different types of businesses?
    Success stories can be used for businesses of all types and sizes. Whether you offer products, services, or solutions, success stories can be tailored to showcase how your offerings have benefited customers in various industries or sectors.
  • How can success stories be obtained from existing customers?
    To obtain success stories from existing customers, you can:

-> Reach out directly: Contact satisfied customers and ask if they would be willing to share their experiences and success stories.

-> Surveys or interviews: Conduct surveys or interviews to gather feedback and success stories from customers who have achieved positive outcomes.

-> Social media monitoring: Monitor social media platforms for any mentions or posts from satisfied customers and engage with them to explore the possibility of sharing their stories.

-> Incentives or rewards: Offer incentives or rewards, such as discounts or exclusive access, to encourage customers to share their success stories.

  • How frequently should success stories be updated or refreshed?
    It is beneficial to regularly update and refresh success stories to keep them relevant and engaging. As new customers succeed and generate new stories, incorporating those into your marketing materials can demonstrate ongoing value and relevance. Additionally, updating success stories periodically showcases your company's continued commitment to delivering positive customer outcomes.

Can success stories be effective in both B2B (business-to-business) and B2C (business-to-consumer) contexts?Success stories can be effective in B2B and B2C contexts. In B2B scenarios, success stories can demonstrate how your product or service has solved complex business challenges and delivered tangible results for other companies. In B2C contexts, success stories can showcase how your offering has improved lives or fulfilled the needs of individual consumers.

By employing these strategies and maintaining curiosity during customer conversations, businesses can create compelling customer stories that resonate with potential customers, enhance social proof, and drive meaningful results.

To begin our journey, we'll first understand the power of storytelling. Humans are hardwired to connect with stories on an emotional level, and businesses can harness this innate inclination to their advantage. By crafting engaging narratives showcasing satisfied customers' real-life experiences, you can create a relatable and trustworthy image that resonates with your target audience. Catch the full webinar here to learn more and master the art of converting customer success stories into new customers.

Nainika Sharma

Stay connected with us.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Ready for the Next Level of Webinars?

Discover how Hubilo's Webinar+ can help you 2X your pipeline

Registration and attendance expansion
Addictive engagement features
Gen-AI Snackable Content Hub to make repurposing a breeze
Revenue Impact Dashboard
and more....
Get a personalized free demo today